How I use an Extensive Processing Instruction (EPI) approach with Entry 3 ESOL students (Part 3)

Featured

This is the final part of a 3-part blog post describing how I implement an EPI approach with my Entry 3 adult ESOL students in the UK. This part covers the Expansion, Autonomy, Routinisation and Spontaneity stages of the MARS-EARS sequence, which forms the framework of the approach. For information about what EPI is and why I use it, please see Parts 1 and 2, where I also talk about the activities I typically do during the earlier stages.

As a reminder, the different stages of the MARS-EARS sequence are:

Modelling

Awareness-Raising

Receptive processing

Structured production

Expansion

Autonomy

Routinisation

Spontaneity

I would like to add the usual disclaimer: I’m not an expert on this approach and neither am I suggesting that this is ‘best practice’ in ESOL teaching. Simply, this is working well for me in my context at the moment, and there might be some useful things for others to take from it and use too.

Stage 5: Expansion (1) – Grammar Focus

Now that the students have read and heard the target language many times, and had the opportunity to produce all the combinations from the sentence builder in speech and in writing, it’s time to take a step back and analyse the grammatical structures of the sentences in greater depth than was previously done during ‘pop-up grammar’. In my context, this usually happens in the 3rd 3-hour lesson of a learning sequence, depending on the length and complexity of the chunks featured. 

Example Advance Organiser / Reference sheet with gaps for students to complete during Expansion phase

During this stage, the underlying patterns in the Sentence Builder are made explicit, and the students get more specific information about how they can manipulate and use the chunks, and how they are linked to other structures they know.

In some ways, this will be similar to the sort of activities I would previously have done during the ‘Presentation’ stage of PPP. I usually display some sentences from the Sentence Builder on the board, and guide the students to notice patterns and use this information to formulate ‘rules’ which they can apply to other sentences. Depending on the structure and the level of the students, I might also introduce more aspects of the structure than have been modelled and practised so far, e.g. 3rd-person in addition to 1st-person forms, or negative in addition to positive forms, or plural in addition to singular forms. Either the students record this information in a partially completed advance organiser, or I give them a reference handout. Personally, I avoid too much grammatical language as I feel it’s just more vocabulary for them to learn, but for some students, the correct terminology can give them the hook they need to remember the information.

This stage is important if we want students to have the ability to produce entirely original sentences, even if the majority of speech consists of prefabricated chunks. The difference between EPI and ‘Grammar + Vocabulary’ is that rather than being presented with a rule and expected to produce original and correct sentences from it straightaway, EPI students already have a number of correct examples in their memories, and simply need to change various elements of these, according to what they want to say. 

To give students more practice of this kind of manipulation, I give them sentences from the Sentence Builder and specify exactly how I would like them to be changed, e.g. “Change this sentence to the past / negative / so it’s about a different person.” I might have these on slides and ask students to write the manipulated sentences on small whiteboards or in their notebooks, or for more pace, I might give them verbally and ask the students to say the manipulated sentence back again.

Examples of slides for sentence manipulation

At this stage I might also use carefully selected form-focussed activities from a coursebook, or, as many teachers do, re-write them using a more ESOL-appropriate context and changing the names to those of students in the class.

Stage 5: Expansion (2) – Different Contexts

This is also the stage where we move away from the context which was used to present the new language, and start to use the chunks in different situations. This involves taking the structures from the Sentence Builder, but using them with different vocabulary items in the various slots, usually recycled from previous topics. 

This might simply mean repeating some of the activities from the Structured Production stage, but with different prompts and freer outcomes, but here are some more activities I like to use during the Expansion stage:

Semi-structured Speaking

This can be a good transition from Structured Production. Students are given prompt questions to answer in pairs. They can answer with language from the Sentence Builder (without looking for most students at this stage) or with their own ideas, using other language they know.

Example slide for a semi-structured speaking task

Substitution

A sentence from the Sentence Builder is displayed with each element highlighted in a different colour. I ask one student to, for example, “Change the blue word(s)”, then another to “Change the yellow word(s)”. After each change we might or might not go back to the original sentence. After a few examples as a class, pairs continue in the same way, changing one word of their choice each time. A nice challenge is for them to see how many different versions of the same pattern they can produce within a certain time limit.

A variation of this is to give the students a number of sentences with one element to change, either individually or in pairs. If possible, to make the task more meaningful, I will ask the students to change the sentences so that they are personal to them. In this example about a Christmas party, I asked the students to rewrite the sentences but changing the blue chunks so that the sentences described a social event that they had been to themselves. For weaker writers in particular, this can be an effective way to scaffold and build up to freer writing tasks.

Example of slide with elements for students to substitute with their own ideas

Sentence Stems

The next step after substituting one vocabulary item for another, is to merely give the students the beginnings of some sentences, and ask them to finish them in any way they like. To differentiate, again, weaker students, or those who have missed sessions can continue to use sentences from the Sentence Builder and stronger students can be encouraged to extend their sentences with coordinating and subordinating conjunctions.

Example sentence stems to practise talking about purpose (Google Form)

Cumulative Games (e.g. “I went to the supermarket and I bought…”)

In this well-known game, the first student finishes the sentence with their idea, the second student repeats the first student’s sentence and then adds their idea and so on. If you want, you can add restrictions such as each addition must start with the next letter in the alphabet, which helps with the memory challenge. This is an extremely versatile game which can be used with almost any chunk of language. Variants I’ve used this year include “As soon as I get home from college, I …” and “While we were at the party, we …”

and / but / because

example of and / but / because

This is a variation of but / because / so from Judith Hochman and Natalie Wexler’s The Writing Revolution. Students are given a single sentence which they need to finish in three different ways, one with each conjunction. I usually start with and, but and because and then add so, although and which as we progress through the year. I have found this activity to be extremely effective in helping students move beyond simple sentences and to start using more compound and complex sentences in their writing.

Example of but / although / because / so

Stage 6: Autonomy

At this stage in the sequence, Dr Conti puts an assessment to see if the students can retrieve all the items from the Sentence Builder, at least receptively. Due to the nature of ESOL teaching, I don’t need an assessment to know that not all my students will be able to do this. But the beauty of EPI is that students who joined the class late, for example, can still access the later stages of the sequence by continuing to use the scaffold of the Sentence Builder. For them, these activities serve as modelling and input tasks, rather than routinisation, but as the structures and language are recycled throughout the year, they will get the opportunity to become more autonomous with these patterns when they come round again.

Stage 7: Routinisation / Automaticity / Fluency

By now, students will be able to use and manipulate the target chunks in a variety of contexts, but it won’t be automatic and will still take a certain amount of thinking time and effort. Previously, I would have gone straight from ‘controlled practice’ to ‘free practice’, but as soon as students were free to use whatever language they wanted, they invariably reverted to previously learnt items and avoided the new ones. 

Our aim during the routinisation stage is to make the retrieval of the chunks from memory much quicker and more fluent, so that the new language items can be effortlessly understood and used in spontaneous production. We can do this by practising the retrieval from memory of these specific items.

These are my current favourite activities to develop fluency, although there are many more on my ‘to try’ list:

4, 3, 2, Speaking

Students prepare a talk which they give to a partner three times, 1 minute quicker each time (i.e. first they have 4 minutes, then 3 minutes and then 2). In between the different times, their partner can give feedback and I will also feed back on anything which I have noted while monitoring. They also change partners so that they are giving the same talk to a different person each time.

Fluency Cards

Student A has a card with sentences or a short text represented by images. They need to use the image prompts to make sentences. Their partner has a card with the sentences on so that they can check their partner’s sentences and give hints if needed. I also give my students these cards to take home for more practice / self-testing. The difficulty is getting the pictures to be as unambiguous as possible, and there are often many possible interpretations. I usually have several options of ‘correct’ sentences on the answer card, and also monitor closely so that I can confirm or correct any other sentences the students try. 

Examples of Fluency Cards

I also have sets of ‘If this is the answer, what is the question?’ cards for students to use in the same way. Student A reads the answer, Student B suggests what the question might be, and Student A checks with the question they have on their card. There is still scope for different possible questions, but it’s less ambiguous than using images. In my experience, this has proved an effective way of consolidating question formation, which was previously somewhat neglected in my teaching.

Example of peer-testing ‘If this is the answer, what is the question?’

Digital Fluency Flashcards

I used these during lockdown, but after I bumped into a student in town who was working through a set on his phone while he was on his way somewhere, I realised they are a useful self-study tool to keep in the repertoire.

I put some sentences from the Sentence Builder onto a slidedeck, one sentence per slide, but only using the first letters of the words. Students need to remember the sentence. Then they can move to the next slide which has the sentence on for them to check. I also inserted an audio recording of the sentence using Mote so that they can check/practise the pronunciation. Having the first letters of the words makes it less of a ‘guess what’s in the teacher’s head’ task, but depending what you want the students to practise, an image on its own might work fine.

In class, I might start a lesson with these slides, asking the students to write the whole sentence on a mini whiteboard, or I might put all the prompts on one slide and challenge them to remember all the sentences with a partner, either orally or writing them down, possibly with a time limit. 

Example Digital Fluency Flashcards

How many sentences can you say in a minute?

Introducing an element of time pressure is very useful at this stage, and any of these fluency tasks can be done against the clock. It forces students to pause, hesitate and think less, and to recall chunks of language without trying to construct sentences one word at a time, which is so important if they are to develop a level of fluency.

“How many sentences about __ can you say in a minute?” can be used with any topic, and some students find the competitive aspect motivating. Of course, ‘winning’ is easier if you use shorter sentences, but in my experience, the stronger students still produce long, complex sentences when playing this game; they just do so quicker and this doesn’t seem to be a disadvantage.

Take it in turns to say a sentence, until someone can’t say anything.

In this variation on the previous activity, pairs take it in turns to give a sentence related to a topic, or to answer a question in different ways, until one of them can’t think of anything to say and has ‘lost’. No doubt someone has given this task a more catchy name at some point, but if they have, I can’t remember what it was!

Alternative Pyramid Translation

Example Pyramid Translation by Gisele Amoros, downloaded from TES: https://www.tes.com/teaching-resource/pyramid-translation-ma-famille-12611234

This is a Conti classic in MfL classes. In groups of three, two students compete to be the first to translate all the sentences into the target language and reach the bottom of the pyramid. A third student has the translation and stops them if they make a mistake, at which point the other student gets a turn, but must start again from the top.

I tried to make a version of this for my ESOL class. Instead of translating, individuals write in the pyramid their answers to a number of questions, each of which also includes the question before, so there is still a cumulative build-up of language. I check their answers are accurate, and then their partner asks the questions one by one, and the students need to give their answers from memory. Their partner has the sheet, and so can check if they are correct, and if they make a mistake, they have to begin again from the top of the pyramid.

I have to admit, this wasn’t very successful in my class. Perhaps the students didn’t understand the task properly, or perhaps it was either too communicative or not communicative enough for it to work as intended. When their partner asked the questions, my students tended to want to give a totally original (and inaccurate) answer rather than the carefully crafted one they had written previously. Nevertheless, I’m including the activity here, as I feel the gradual build-up and repetition of the sentences is powerful and has real potential. Perhaps you’ll find a way to make it work. Next time, I might use a pre-prepared story about a 3rd person for this activity, and leave students’ genuine communication about their own experiences for other tasks. 

My experimental alternative to a pyramid translation

*****

Of course, it will take more than a lesson of routinisation tasks for students to reach an adequate level of fluency. This stage goes beyond the end of the MARSEARS sequence, with students asked to recall language from previous Sentence Builders throughout the year. In my classes this is often with ‘Can you remember…?’ type activities as a Do Now or warmer, or through language games, but this can be a bit haphazard. One of my personal goals for the next academic year is to be more systematic with my recycling.

Example Retrieval Practice slides

Another way that I build in retrieval practice is through the low-stakes vocabulary ‘test’ I give my students every lesson. These will be words or chunks from a Sentence Builder which they already know receptively. I tell them which words they will be tested on so that they can practise and usually I make a quick Google Form quiz for them to practise with as well, but the key feature for retrieval is that the test will always be on 8 of the new words/chunks, 1 item from the last test, and 1 item from any previous test. The test itself will either be ‘Here’s a picture – write the word(s)’, or I will give a definition or synonym and they will write the corresponding word(s). If students want to get 10/10, they need to be regularly testing themselves on previous items, either using the paper-based reference sheets I have given them, or the digital flashcards and quizzes available to them on Google Classroom.

Stage 8: Spontaneity

This stage is what I might previously have called ‘Freer Practice’, and it is where the students are free to use whatever language they like, although the tasks invite the use of the target language practised in the previous stages. The activities at this stage are very familiar to ESOL teachers: pair / small group / whole class discussion; role-play; describing a picture; extended writing tasks in semi-authentic contexts; task-based activities etc., or this might be the time for one of our internal Progress Checks, or maybe an external exam. The difference now is that since adopting EPI with all its different stages, when I get to this stage, the students actually use the new language we’ve been practising. 

Final Thoughts

I should probably add that this isn’t the only thing that goes on in my classroom. It is how I teach new language items – grammar, vocabulary and communicative functions – but I still do ‘normal’ reading and listening comprehension tasks alongside, and there are plenty of opportunities for students to talk about whatever is going on in their lives, with a focus on communication rather than accuracy.

2021-2022 was the first academic year I followed the MARS-EARS sequence through fully from beginning to end across several topics and without too much pandemic disruption. I can’t tell you that my exam results were any different from what they usually are, which probably says more about the exam board we use than anything else, but I was very happy with my own observations of the progress my students had made. Listening back to the exam recordings I heard sentence after sentence that had originally come from a Sentence Builder, and here they were being used effortlessly and appropriately, by all students, irrespective of prior achievement or perceived ‘ability’.

One student who had previously passed Level 2 with a different provider, but was in my Entry 3 class last year after our more robust initial assessment, remarked at the end of the year: “[previous provider] taught me to pass the exam, but you teach me what I need for my life.” (paraphrased) That’s good enough for me.

Here are three pieces of work, shared with permission, showing the progress following the introduction of EPI of a student who has been in my class a long time and who previously seemed to have plateaued. These were all written in class in test conditions.

Term 1 Progress Check 2019
End of ‘Talking About Everyday Life’ unit – free writing 2020
End of ‘Talking About Everyday Life’ unit – free writing 2021

Next Steps

Perhaps, having read this, you are interested in trying an EPI approach yourself. To completely change everything, wholesale, is very daunting, and I would suggest simply trying a few new activities, as I did, and see how the students respond. If unsure where to start, my recommendation would be activities from the Receptive Processing and Routinisation stages as they were notably absent from my activity repertoire, coming from a CELTA / Skills for Life background. Then you might consider seeing what your next language teaching point would look like if you presented it as a Sentence Builder. There are plenty of examples online, some better quality than others, which you can use for inspiration. And then it’s a case of gradually introducing more EPI activities, and putting some thought into the sequencing of the items and where they will be recycled.

Since I wrote the first parts of this blog, Gianfranco Conti published this post which aims to clarify misinterpretations of his approach and is a clear step-by-step guide I wish I’d had years ago.

And for more detailed information, including hundreds of activities to try, his and Steve Smith’s book Breaking the Sound Barrier is indispensable:

I’m very happy to answer any questions – just pop them in the comments. And I’m very keen to hear from other ESOL teachers trying this approach. Please do share how it’s going for you.

Enjoy!

How I use an Extensive Processing Instruction (EPI) approach with Entry 3 ESOL students (Part 2)

This is the second of a 3-part blog post. Together, the three parts describe how I implement an EPI approach with my Entry 3 adult ESOL students in the UK. This part covers the Awareness-Raising, Receptive Processing and Structured Production stages of the MARS-EARS sequence. For information about what EPI is and why I’m such a fan, please see Part 1, where I also talk about the activities I typically do during the Modelling stage.

As a reminder, the different stages of the MARS-EARS sequence are:

Modelling

Awareness-Raising

Receptive processing

Structured production

Expansion

Autonomy

Routinisation

Spontaneity

I would like to add the usual disclaimer: I’m not an expert on this approach and neither am I suggesting that this is ‘best practice’. Simply, this is working well for me in my context at the moment, and there might be some useful things for others to take from it and use too.

Stage 2: Awareness-Raising

Once my students have heard and read the sentences from the Sentence Builder plenty of times, it’s time to direct their attention to any notable linguistic features. The purpose of this stage is to sensitise the students to grammatical elements which they might not necessarily notice when focussing purely on meaning and understanding. 

For example, from the example Sentence Builder on comparing places previously shared in Part 1, I might draw the students’ attention to the comparative forms ‘bigger’, ‘busier’, ‘more crowded’ and ‘more multicultural’ and ask them if they can see from the examples why the comparative might be sometimes formed with ‘-er’ and sometimes with ‘more’. Probably I’ll ask them to discuss this with a partner, to ensure maximum participation, and then pairs can feed back to the class, or I will briefly explain the general rule myself if no-one else can. And that’s it. Just a couple of minutes – no copying rules or exercises to practice applying them or anything else at this stage other than noticing the pattern.

I have found that this kind of ‘Pop-up Grammar’, as Gianfranco Conti calls it, is more successful in terms of helping students acquire grammatical structures, compared to, say, a big one-off ‘comparatives’ lesson. Drip-feeding, little and often, means that there are more opportunities for more students to notice a structure when they are personally ready to acquire it. Also, the repeated cycle of forgetting and remembering means a structure is more likely to be remembered long-term, and, particularly in ESOL, if we only teach comparatives in one lesson, what happens to the student who happens to miss that lesson? They’ve missed their one opportunity to encounter that structure.

‘Comparing Places’ Sentence Builder

Awareness-raising is not restricted to grammatical patterns. If there’s an interesting spelling pattern, I might focus in on that, highlight the pattern in a different colour, talk about the pronunciation, see if the students can connect it to any other words they know with the same pattern etc. The ‘-igh’ in ‘slightly’ stands out for me in this example as a spelling pattern that might be worth pointing out. At this stage, I could also take the opportunity to remind the students of any capitalisation or punctuation rules that feature. For example, “Why does ‘Doncaster’ need a capital ‘D’? Tell your partner.” I might also slip in any helpful information about etymology or morphology, for example, “Why do we need double -g in ‘bigger’?”

Stage 3: Receptive Processing

In terms of lesson planning, the Modelling, Awareness-Raising and Receptive Processing stages can be loosely grouped together to form a continuum of activities which start with simple repetition and gradually require students to focus on and process different aspects of the input. To my mind, the activities described in this section are not uniquely receptive processing activities; they are activities which I use during the MAR part of the sequence, but which require a greater depth of processing than the activities I described in Part 1 of this blog post. Of course, I’m quite happy to be corrected if there is more of a distinction than I have noticed.

One of the best things about EPI activities is that they can be adapted to practice different areas of language, or a single activity can be self-differentiating and in itself meet the different needs of different students. For example, at this stage I will always do some kind of dictation activity. If I use a ‘Partial Dictation’ where I give the students a text with gaps which they must fill in as I read the text, I can control where the gaps are, depending on what I want them to focus on: I can leave gaps for ‘content’ words if I want them to process the meaning of the sentence; I can leave gaps for auxiliaries and verb endings if I want them to focus on tenses; I can leave gaps for all the articles if I want them to notice words that are commonly not noticed or I can leave gaps for all the words containing a specific spelling pattern I want to sensitise students to etc. If I had all the planning time in the world, or if I really wanted to impress an observer, I could produce differently gapped texts for different students, but personally I’ve never found the time to do this. 

Here is an example of a partial dictation I used based on my ‘Lifestyle Changes’ sentence builder, in which I wanted students to focus on the verbs we use to talk about the future:

Example partial dication activity

Alternatively, I can use a standard dictation and read out a list of sentences or a paragraph for the students to write. Then, when students self-check with the correct sentences on the board, they can process the areas of difficulty which are specific to them, whether that is grammar, missing articles, spelling, punctuation or whatever.

Dictation is pretty old-school, but in my experience, adult ESOL students find dictation tasks useful and enjoyable. Gianfranco Conti and Steve Smith give ideas for several different dictation tasks in Breaking the Sound Barrier and another useful, if a little old-fashioned, source of fun dictation activities is Dictation by Paul Davis and Mario Rinvolucri.

Another brilliant feature of EPI is how easy it is to either scaffold the activities or ramp up the challenge for those that need it. For example, during any of the activities described here, those students who need to can refer to the sentence builder, and those who need a bit more challenge can try the activities without looking. As a half-way stage, students who have been relying on a sentence builder with items translated can be given one without translations to work from. It is also easy, with a bit of cutting and pasting from the sentence builder, to provide a scaffold of partially completed answers, e.g. for dyslexic or low-literacy students, or in mixed level classes. It doesn’t take no time at all, but it is more time-efficient than planning completely different tasks for different students, and allows all students to participate in the same activity which builds group cohesion.

Here are some more of my favourite activities to use during the MAR stages:

Narrow Listening

I talked about Narrow Reading in my last post, but I forgot to talk about how I do Narrow Listening. As a reminder, Narrow Listening texts are short, highly repetitive and very similar linguistically. They provide students with flooded input of the target chunks and structures and opportunity to process them repeatedly and extensively. The trouble is, it takes quite a lot of time and effort to produce such recordings. At the moment, I use Elllo Mixer, which has recordings of six people all talking about the same topic, and write my own gist and detailed listening tasks. But of course these recordings aren’t based on my sentence builder, and most are too linguistically varied to be effective Listening As Modelling texts. I’m hoping that I can convert some colleagues to EPI and we can invest some CPD time into producing some decent narrow listening texts.

Sentence Chaos

This one probably belongs closer to the M than the R of the MAR continuum, but I forgot about it last time and it’s a good one.

10 or so sentences are displayed on the board. I read them in a random order and the students write the numbers of the sentences in the order that I say them.

Example slide for ‘Sentence Chaos’

As an alternative, students can do the same in pairs and for an extra challenge, they have to repeat the sentences in the same order, rather than noting down the numbers.

I’ve found the urgency of this task has really helped my ESOL students develop their scanning skills and get past having to read every single word in a sentence.

Spot the Difference 

In this task, pairs are given nearly identical texts. Student A reads their text to Student B who listens, reads their own text and highlights / underlines / ‘corrects’ any differences. Then B reads their version of the text to A who does the same. Then they both read both texts to check they found all the differences. This is another activity where I can control the focus of the task by choosing what the specific differences will be.

Here is an example of Spot the Difference texts I used with my ‘Healthy Diet’ sentence builder:

Example ‘Spot the Difference’ activity

Written Sentence Puzzles

I’ve found this to be one of the most useful activities for my students, particularly for helping them with word order.

First, I display a slide with the sentence builder headings. Here’s an example from my ‘Changes’ sentence builder:

Next, I read sentences from the sentence builder, but jumbled up. For example, “started learning English which is great have since I came to Sheffield I .” Students need to write the sentence in the correct order, using the headings to help them. Usually I ask them to do this on mini-whiteboards so that I can easily scan all of their answers, and then I’ll show the correct answer on the next slide for them to self-check. At first I keep the chunks together, but as students get more proficient I might separate more items, e.g. “started learning which is have English great I to Sheffield since I came.” If I want to give them even more challenge, I will remove the headings from the board.

Note: EPI teachers also do this activity verbally: the teacher says the jumbled sentence and the students repeat it but in the correct order. I’ve found this less successful with my ESOL students. I don’t know if it’s more challenging for older students or if it’s just my classroom routines around not shouting out and listening to each others’ answers are not as good as they should be. I think I also prefer the written version because it ensures higher participation as all the students are processing and writing the sentence, not just those I call on to answer.

Making a Judgement

In this activity, I say or display a sentence and the students need to decide if it is correct or not. I can quickly get answers from all students by asking for a thumbs up or thumbs down, or if I can be bothered with the faff of handing them out, I can use my RAG cards. Alternatively, I could say or display 3 or 4 sentences and the students need to decide which one is correct.

RAG cards

The sentences I use could have any kind of error, depending on what I want the class to focus on, or they could be grammatically correct but with a nonsensical meaning like ‘Last June we had a Christmas party at college.’

Example ‘Make a Judgement’ slide

Caution: There is a strong argument against showing incorrect examples in that it is modelling errors which students might then acquire. I try to guard against this by modelling lots of correct sentences first and for this to be an activity whereby students analyse and articulate why the answer they know to be right is right, rather than an activity through which they learn which is the correct option. I also try to reinforce the correct sentences by striking through all the incorrect answers on the next slide (alt + shift + 5 is a really handy keyboard shortcut).

Top Tip: If you’re printing your own RAG cards, make sure you print double-sided or sometimes you can’t tell which card they’re holding up. I also encourage my students to use the question mark if they aren’t sure and then I’ll know they’ve not just made a lucky guess.

Stage 4: Structured Production

In an ideal world, before moving on to this stage, all students will have thorough receptive knowledge of all the items on the sentence builder. Of course ESOL classes can be quite disrupted with students missing classes or portions of classes for various reasons. So it sometimes happens that the first time a student sees a sentence builder is at the Structured Production stage. It’s the nature of our context, but this is no worse than how I used to teach, where all students would be expected to produce language items almost straight away as a matter of course. At least now I can give students the sentence builder and release some tasks on Google Classroom for them to still get some receptive practice.

Sometimes the transition to Structured Production is nice and clear cut: I have one quite meaty sentence builder, I spend one 3 hour lesson on MAR activities plus Reading As Modelling for homework, and then the next lesson we move on to Structured Production. But depending on the topic it can be a bit messy. At the moment I’m teaching ‘Describe a Social Event in the Past’ which comprises a few mini sentence builders covering place and time of the event, purpose of the event etc:

So far, we’ve had one MAR lesson on the first sentence builder and another MAR lesson using that one and adding the three little ones. Next lesson I’m planning MAR activities focussing on the last sentence builder and then starting to move to structured production. It’s messy.

By the time we reach the Structured Production phase of the MARS-EARS framework, I’m on more familiar ground. This stage is quite similar to the ‘Practise’ part of PPP and I can use many of my standard activities: substitution drills, information gap activities, pair and cross–class Q & A, mingles, class surveys etc. The difference now is that these activities are a bit more structured and restrictive in the language they practise and only require the students to use items from the sentence builder.

Another difference is, because of all the work at the previous stages, these activities are now a lot more successful. Students have heard, read, said and processed the sentences many times and are really clear on the meanings, so now they can focus on starting to use them themselves for proper communication. In terms of cognitive load, moving to production too early puts too much strain on working memory, as students would be still grappling with meaning, decoding, processing, pronunciation and so on, on top of trying to put what they want to say into words.

Here are some newer additions to my Structured Production activity repertoire, which I’ve learnt from EPI teachers:

Delayed copying

Delayed copying is an activity I always use to transition from receptive processing to structured production. It’s very similar to ‘Delayed Repetition’, which I described in Part 1, but in this activity the output is writing rather than speaking.

The students read a sentence and then have to hold it in their heads for 5 seconds or so (I use a slide animation where a lady walks across the screen) and then they write it. The reason this exercise is so powerful is that all through the delay between reading and writing they are replaying and rehearsing the sentence in their heads, which helps get it into their long-term memory. For ESOL students, for whom literacy is often a big issue, this activity also helps practise spelling. Essentially, it’s a lot like ‘Look Say Cover Write Check’, but more fun, and involves spelling the words in context.

Trapdoor

In this activity, students copy 4 sentences, but for one of the chunks in each sentence they have to choose a chunk from three given options. They don’t show their partner their sentences, but their partner has to read all four sentences, guessing which of the options their partner chose. If they guess wrong at any stage, they have to start again from sentence number 1.

Disappearing Text

After lots of receptive work on a text, display or read it with words missing, and ask the students to give the missing word, either orally, or in writing (again, I use small whiteboards for this task, for ease of checking). It’s possible to do this several times, removing more words each time until the students have effortlessly committed to memory an entire paragraph, full of useful chunks for them to use themselves in future production tasks.

Rebuild sentences from initial letters

I use a lot of recall / retrieval practice activities in my classes. Often these are along the lines of ‘Can you remember these words / phrases / sentences from last lesson?’ accompanied by a visual prompt. Using initial letters stops the task being impossible with complex sentences and goes some way to prevent this type of activity being more like ‘guess what’s in the teacher’s head.’

Activities for independent study

As in all ESOL contexts, contact time is at a premium. In my organisation, it is the expectation that students do two hours of independent study each week. More and more, my colleagues are setting this work online. Personally, I haven’t yet felt the need to use anything other than a Google Form set as a quiz, which can do almost everything I would like to be able to do and is, of course, self-checking. At this stage, for independent work my go-tos are multiple-choice gap-fills, choosing the best ending for a sentence, re-writing sentences with missing vowels and putting words in the right order to make a sentence.

Again, once you have the sentence builder, creating these quizzes is quite a simple cutting and pasting job with only a little thinking required to check for things like the possibility of multiple answers.

Next on Catrin’s ESOL blog:

In Part 3, I will talk about how I implement the EARS stage of the framework, where students move away from the sentence builder and head towards automaticity and fluency. 

Meanwhile, as mentioned previously, Gianfranco Conti and Steve Smith’s ‘Breaking the Sound Barrier’ features hundreds more activities to try.

How I use an Extensive Processing Instruction (EPI) approach with Entry 3 ESOL students (Part 1)

Introduction: Why EPI for ESOL?

Until relatively recently, had anyone asked me what my preferred language teaching approach was, my reply, like most ESOL teachers, would have been ‘Principled Eclecticism.’ Over time I built up a repertoire of activities from a variety of sources, supported by what I’ve read about language acquisition, and which experience taught me work well in my context (adult ESOL in an English FE college). But the better I got at Assessment for Learning, the more frustrated I got by some of my students’ apparent lack of progress. Stronger students did just fine, getting better at using what they already knew, acquiring new items implicitly, or through well-established study skills and passing exams easily as they were already more or less at the required level. But a growing number of my Entry 3 students seemed stuck. They’d somehow scraped through our (teacher-assessed) Entry 2 exams but after several years in my Entry 3 class were making very little progress. It seemed that many activities in my repertoire provided students with the opportunity to practise language they already had, but weren’t particularly effective at helping them learn new lexis and structures. And my communicative approach to grammar, through a variety of controlled and freer practice activities just never seemed to reach the end goal of the students actually acquiring and using the target structures. The ‘stuck’ students simply didn’t have enough language to make much use of the class activities, and the activities I was using to help them acquire new language weren’t working well enough or quickly enough. For many of my students, my activity selection wasn’t hitting the sweet spot at the centre of the effective/efficient/enjoyable Venn diagram.

I started reading about EPI a few years ago, and at first I was seduced by the activities: like the offspring of a marriage between Communicative Language Teaching and the Lexical Approach, the activities I saw EPI followers using were simple, low-prep, fun and soundly based on Second Language Acquisition research, but I’d never come across anything like them in any textbook or training.

Gradually, I started adding activities from the EPI methodology to my own eclectic repertoire, and I found students responded well to them. Then over time, I started to notice improvements in their output. ‘Chunks’ of language which we’d practised the EPI way were coming out more in freer practice activities, students who I’d thought had totally fossilised started producing sentences with correct word order, and sentence level grammar was getting more accurate, although I was doing less and less specific grammar teaching. Most importantly, the ‘stuck’ students no longer seemed stuck. Progress was still slow, but I could see it. They could say and write things which they couldn’t have done a few months previously, and it felt like they had the beginnings of a stable framework of interlanguage which they could start adding new items to.

So I read more, tried more of the activities, and slowly my planning evolved to follow the MARS-EARS framework more systematically. And as I reflect now, several years down the line, there’s relatively little that I do in my classes that is outside of EPI methodology. As Twitter folk might say, my teaching has been almost totally ‘Contified’.

I should say, though, that I’m in no way an expert on this approach. Each time I work through the MARS-EARS sequence I make notes of things to do differently and better the next time, and there are literally hundreds of activities associated with the methodology that are still on my ‘to try’ list. But I’m so convinced that other ESOL teachers will find it useful that I’m not going to wait any longer to share what I do.

This three part blog post will briefly outline the EPI approach, and then I’ll describe how I typically implement each of the MARS-EARS stages with my Entry 3 class, including my favourite tried-and-tested activities at each stage. I’m not at all suggesting that this is ‘best practice’, just that this is working well for me in my context at the moment, and there might be some useful things for you to take from it and use too.

My Repertoire

As an aside, I’ve talked quite a lot already about my activity repertoire, so it might be worth showing what it looks like. It is an actual spreadsheet. I have different columns for different lesson stages, and underneath I list the activities I could use at each stage. The activities are ranked, with the ones I consider to be better closer to the top. When I come across new activities, they go ‘below the line’ on the ‘to try’ list, and have to audition and prove themselves effective before getting included in the repertoire. I have the spreadsheet open while I’m planning, and simply choose activities appropriate to where we’re at in the sequence, taking into account what we’ve done recently and the needs and preferences of the particular group. The spreadsheet is constantly evolving as new activities gain ascendency and old ones fall by the wayside, but at the moment here is what a bit of it looks like:

What is EPI?

The EPI approach, based on the MARS-EARS sequence, is attributable to Gianfranco Conti and arose out of his PhD research into Second Language Acquisition. Other chunk-based and input-focussed approaches are available, but to my mind, none are so completely described and easy to put into practice as this one. For a full and detailed description of EPI from the man himself, these two Gianfranco Conti blog posts are a good place to start: https://gianfrancoconti.com/2018/07/30/patterns-first-how-i-teach-lexicogrammar-part-1/ 

https://gianfrancoconti.com/2018/12/05/how-i-teach-lexicogrammar-part-2-the-8-tenets-of-extensive-processing-instruction-in-the-novice-to-intermediate-classroom/

or you could watch this 45 minute youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKFvYUPYbUg&t=14s

In brief, EPI focuses on patterns and chunks of language, rather than isolated words and grammar rules. Dr Conti describes it as a Lexicogrammar approach. The choice of lexis and structures is driven by communicative function (e.g. ‘Describing a Place’), with the aim that novice-intermediate level learners will be able to communicate easily and effectively in real-life situations. Chunks are continually recycled throughout the sequence.

EPI focuses on depth of learning over breadth, or quality over quantity, if you like. Fewer language items are ‘covered’, but they are REALLY learnt.

There is no language/skills distinction, but the target chunks are practised through all four skills. 

Grammar is integral to the approach, but is not focussed on explicitly until students are already using the chunks of language which feature the target structures confidently in communicative activities.

And what makes EPI most distinctive for me is the emphasis on input. Underpinning the methodology is the research that shows that input must be 95-98% comprehensible in order for language acquisition to take place. I’d come across this figure many times, but before EPI not really known how to implement it, except through extensive reading projects. The MARS-EARS sequence is built around a single Sentence Builder which is exploited and manipulated in many ways and students are not expected to produce any of the target language until they have had extensive exposure and thoroughly processed it through a range of receptive activities. It is these activities in particular which were missing from my repertoire, in that it is these activities that bridge the gap between comprehensible input and acquisition.

The different stages of the MARS-EARS sequence are:

Modelling

Awareness-raising

Receptive processing

Structured production

Expansion

Autonomy

Routinisation

Spontaneity

To my mind, the framework is not unlike the famous P-P-P model from CELTA courses, although others disagree. It seems to me it goes through similar stages, just over a longer timescale. What differentiates it from P-P-P, however, are the specific activities which the students engage in at each stage.

Typically, the MARS-EARS stages are worked through over a number of lessons. I find it generally takes me 3 x 3-hr lessons plus a couple of hours of independent practice (homework) to work through the entire sequence, depending on the topic and what other things I want to be doing with the class, for example if it’s Bonfire Night, or if they need exam practice, or if it’s target-setting week etc.

The approach is ideal for beginners, but it does require a level of literacy, so in an ESOL context it is appropriate for Entry 1 classes where the students are already literate, and perfect for Entry 2 and the lower end of Entry 3. By the end of Entry 3 you’d probably need to be supplementing with ‘other stuff’ to make sure students are exposed to a wide enough range of language and text-type. In my opinion, other approaches might be more appropriate for Level 1 and Level 2, although a Sentence Builder with accompanying activities would still be my go-to if I was introducing a new structure.

Stage 1: Modelling

The aim of the Modelling stage is for the students to hear and read the target language multiple times – to be flooded with comprehensible input. The first thing to do is to put together the Sentence Builder that will be the basis for all the activities. You could see it as a reference document, or a kind of Learning Outcome. These are the chunks of language that my students will be able to understand and use at the end of the sequence.

Sentence Builders

Here is an example Sentence Builder based on the micro-function ‘Comparing Places’ which I taught as part of a broader ‘Describing a Place’ topic:

Sentence Builders are nothing new. In the old days we would have called them ‘substitution tables’, although the substitution tables I was trained to use were built around grammatical structures rather than communicative functions, and it is how Sentence Builders are used within the EPI methodology which makes them so useful.

Compiling the Sentence Builder is the hardest and most time-consuming part of the whole process. I want to choose items which will be most useful for the students, so high frequency items from real-world contexts are essential, but which items to include? And more importantly, which to leave out? I’d like to involve the students in choosing the items to practise and learn, but of course they don’t know what they don’t know. As a compromise, it is me who chooses the items, but I choose them from the sprawling spreadsheet of students’ ‘emergent language’ that I call my ‘E3 ESOL Lexicon’. This is the place where I collect and record all the words and phrases that come up during lessons and get written on the board. I’m in the habit now of quickly adding them to the spreadsheet after the class, loosely organised by topic, or at least taking a photo and adding them later. Then, when I’m writing or revising a sentence builder on that topic, I make sure to include words that have come up before which my students have needed to use. It’s a very messy spreadsheet with many sheets. Here’s an example:

One day I’ll tidy it up a bit and make it look pretty. And sometimes I ponder whether it would be possible to use this to produce an alternative curriculum, based on lexis rather than structures or skills…

In addition to items from my spreadsheet, I use my professional judgement to choose items I think will be useful for my students. I’ll also browse various published resources to check there’s nothing obvious I’ve forgotten. My favourites for this are Oxford Word Skills and the old Innovations series. If it’s a completely new topic, I might do a DOGME style lesson first in order to generate the emergent language which will then go into the sentence builder.

One of the reasons the Sentence Builder is such a powerful tool is that it is self-differentiating and can cater for the needs of all learners. There is no requirement for all students to learn all items in the sentence builder – they can choose the most relevant if they want. I can include useful but structurally ‘difficult’ items, because the students will learn them as a chunk with no need to understand the underlying grammar rules. And there is space to add any other items that come up during the classes. The Sentence Builder is also perfect for introducing stretch and challenge, or providing a scaffold if needed: during class activities, strong students can attempt the tasks without looking at the Sentence Builder, if they feel they are ready, and weaker students can have access to the Sentence Builder to make more challenging tasks accessible to them.

Personally, I consider myself to be still a novice Sentence Builder creator. You will see from the example above that I broke the Number 1 Rule: All combinations must be possible. But from my Sentence Builder, students could construct the sentence ‘My street is bigger than Doncaster.’ which I suppose is technically possible, but unlikely. I also struggle with getting the balance right between including enough items to be worthwhile, but not so many as to overwhelm. But perfection is the enemy of good, and this is good enough for me for now.

To read more about creating Sentence Builders from a pro, Dylan Vinales’ blog is well worth a look.

As mentioned before, producing quality Sentence Builders is time-consuming. If anyone reading this would like to collaborate and share, that would be fantastic. I have some available for free and to purchase in my TES shop and it is my intention to add more this year. Producing a book is on my long-term to-do list, but the day job has been a bit too full-on to think about this recently.

Presentation of new language

As you will have seen if you have followed any of the links, Gianfranco Conti’s teaching context is school-based MfL, and a key feature of his and Dylan Vinales’ sentence builders is that all items are translated to the students’ first language (in their case, English). This is not an option for us in ESOL, although it’s something I’m thinking about, given how good Google Translate is getting. But at the moment I present the new language in the ‘usual way’: a clear context, lots of images and further verbal explanations and examples as needed. I then ask students to discuss with a partner who shares a language how they might translate the items into their shared language, and to write translations directly onto the Sentence Builder. Dictionaries, translators, phones etc can be used at any time in my classes as well. We’re going to be spending a lot of time practising these language items, so it’s vital that they are understood correctly.

Activities during the Modelling stage

Once I’m as confident as I can be that all students correctly understand all the items on the Sentence Builder, we’ll start with lots of reading aloud and ‘listen and repeat’ type activities, using sentences from the Sentence Builder displayed on a Google Slide. You might call this drilling. To keep it fun, I ask students to repeat the sentences using different voices, e.g. ‘as if you are angry’ or ‘as if you have a cold’ or to whisper or shout the example sentences. Sometimes I split the sentences in half and half the class read one half of the sentence, and the other half read the other half.

Here are some more activities which I have found work well with my adult ESOL students at this stage:

Mind Reading

10 or so sentences from the Sentence Builder are displayed on a Google Slide. Students choose one sentence and write it down in secret. Their partner has to guess which sentence they chose. Depending on the topic, it might be a sentence that is true for them that their partner has to guess. In my experience, this activity goes down very well and I couldn’t tell you why it’s so popular, but it gives the students lots of opportunity to hear and say the target sentences so I’m not complaining.

Top Tip: Don’t number the sentences or the students will just say the number and not actually read out the sentence.

Here’s the slide I used for ‘Mind Reading’ based on the ‘Comparing Places’ sentence builder:

Delayed Repetition

I say a sentence from the Sentence Builder. Students need to hold it in their head for 8 seconds or so and then repeat. I used to count the seconds, but recently I learnt how to use object animations to make a lady walk off the screen. While she’s walking, the students are ‘playing’ the sentence over and over in their heads and once she’s left the screen they have to repeat the sentence. 

This example is from the micro-function ‘Describing rules and customs’, which I taught, again, as part of the wider ‘Describing a Place’ topic:

Sentence Stealers

This one’s a cracker, but unfortunately not suitable in times of Covid. 

12 or so model sentences from the Sentence Builder are displayed on a slide.

Students choose 4 of the sentences and secretly write them on 4 separate slips of scrap paper.

Students mingle and try to ‘steal’ as many sentences as they can from the other students. They steal sentences by approaching another student and reading any 4 sentences from the board. If they read any of the other student’s sentences, they get to keep those pieces of paper.

The winner is the student with the most pieces of paper at the end of an agreed time, e.g. 5 minutes.

Top tip: Model carefully making it clear that students can guess from any of the sentences on the board; they shouldn’t be reading their own sentences and seeing if their partner has the same, because then their partner will know which sentences they have.

Extra challenge: If playing this game later in the sequence, you could start to remove odd words from the sentences as the game progresses, to practise recall.

Phonologically Specific Activities

At this stage I will also include plenty of activities with a phonics focus and which give students the opportunity to practise processing and pronouncing specific sounds. Here are some favourites:

Auditory discrimination with minimal pairs

I repeat in random order two words related to the sentence builder which are often confused, e.g. ‘than’ and ‘then’. Students listen and raise their left hand if they think I said ‘than’ and their right if they think I said ‘then’. I might just use the two words, or I might use a list of different words which feature the same sounds. Incidentally, this is a good activity for helping students distinguish between 13 and 30.

Note: Gianfranco Conti calls this activity ‘Contrast Response’.

Faulty Echo

I read a word from the sentence builder first with correct pronunciation and then with a common pronunciation error. Students tell their partner which sound was wrong and why.

Note: This is a classic EPI activity, but I find it works better with ESOL students with some variations to give greater challenge, maybe because they have more exposure to spoken language than MfL pupils. I’ve had more success simply pronouncing words incorrectly and asking students to correct me, or getting them to listen to a whole sentence and count how many pronunciation errors I made. Another alternative is to use the correct/incorrect pair but ask the students to identify which is correct and why.

Gapped Letters

Students are given a text flooded with 3 target sounds, making sure I only use one spelling pattern for each particular sound. From the Sentence Builder example above, I might contrive a text featuring lots of words containing the sounds ‘wor’ like in ‘worse’ and ‘er’ like in ‘better’ and split digraph ‘i_e’ like in ‘quite’. All the target sounds are gapped in the text. I read the text and students listen, filling in the gaps.

Break the Flow

Students are given a text, or some sentences, with all the gaps between words removed. I read the text at a natural speed and students draw lines to show the boundaries between the words.

Narrow Reading / Narrow Listening

Narrow reading or listening texts are short, highly repetitive and very similar linguistically. They provide students with flooded input of the target chunks and structures and the opportunity to process them repeatedly and extensively.

These are the narrow reading texts I used with my ‘Giving Personal Details’ sentence builder:

I use similar skimming, scanning, detailed reading and vocabulary tasks to what I would ordinarily use in a reading activity, but the difference is that, rather than having reading comprehension as an aim, the purpose of these tasks is for students to acquire the repeated chunks and structures and use them in their own output. Gianfranco Conti refers to activities with narrow reading or listening texts as RAM and LAM – Reading as Modelling and Listening as Modelling.

Next on Catrin’s ESOL blog:

It was my intention to look at Awareness-Raising and Receptive Processing in this part, but this post is plenty long enough already, so please look out for Part 2 in which I’ll describe the activities which I have found most effective at those stages, along with the transition from receptive to structured production activities.

Meanwhile, for literally hundreds more lexicogrammar activities, please read Gianfranco Conti and Steve Smith’s amazing book Breaking the Sound Barrier, from which I got most, if not all the activities mentioned here.

Process / Product and de-cluttering ESOL

I had an interesting disagreement with a colleague recently. We were discussing Ofsted’s new ‘deep dive’ policy and what we would be able to show them if they wanted to scrutinise our learners’ work. I argued that work that is done solely in order to practise a particular skill or language point doesn’t need to be kept once the practice has been completed; it has served its purpose and there is no point hanging on to that particular piece of paper. My colleague seemed surprised at this attitude, expecting, both as a student and a teacher, that all work would be kept. We agreed to disagree.

I can’t really object to students keeping hold of every single worksheet I give them, or every little bit of writing they do in class. It doesn’t affect me, and it might be that we have to do it ‘for Ofsted’ (not a good reason for doing anything, in my opinion). But in terms of language learning I don’t think it’s useful or necessary, and it could even be detrimental. In this blog I will explain why.

By way of analogy, let’s compare learning a language with learning a musical instrument. At the moment I’m trying to get better at playing the violin. An incredibly useful tool is to record myself and listen back to the recording. I notice things I wouldn’t otherwise in the moment of playing, and I pick up on things I need to work on. Similarly in my band we record our rehearsals, listen back together and discuss any changes we think we should make to the arrangement or the song composition itself. But we don’t need to keep these recordings. For a start, I don’t have the space either for hundreds of CDs, or on my hard drive. But the point is, once I’ve listened to the recording and taken away what I need to work on, I don’t actually need it any more. Practising, recording and listening back is part of the process of honing my skill with the purpose of producing an amazing album further down the line. Now that CD, the final ‘product’ if you like, I will keep and treasure possibly for ever (yes, I’m old. I still like to hold an actual CD in my hands).

To return to ESOL teaching, I think (hope) no one would think we need to record every speaking activity and keep it in a computer file somewhere. Students do the activity, the teacher monitors, gives feedback and plans further work based on issues and language which came up during the activity. Job done. Why should it be any different with writing activities, just because it’s less faff to keep hold of a piece of paper than record and keep an audio file?

My students do a lot of writing practice in class. Sometimes it’s worksheet based, for example using a writing frame, but more often than not I put questions on the board for them to write answers to, or the beginnings of sentences for them to finish. I monitor, provide vocabulary and spellings, remind about punctuation, guide learners to self-correct errors – all the usual things. After they finish I share with the whole group any particularly excellent sentences and feedback on issues which are relevant to everyone. I also make notes of things that will need a whole lesson in the future. But in the same way that I don’t feel the need to record and keep any speaking activities, I see no reason for this writing to be kept once the students have had the feedback. New lexical items get recorded in their vocabulary books, spellings get recorded on their LSCWC sheets and this year I’ve asked my students to keep a sheet at the front of their files for ‘Things I need to remember’ where I, or they, can put reminders like ‘Don’t forget a full stop at the end of a sentence!’ or ‘I have / she has‘. The actual writing has served its purpose and is now defunct. In fact, more and more I use mini whiteboards for this kind of activity so the question of whether to keep it or not becomes irrelevant.

I think part of the problem is that conventional ESOL worksheets tend to be a combination of different elements. There might be a short text followed by some comprehension questions, then maybe some vocabulary matching and some sentences from the text which exemplify a structure and some exercises to practise the structure. Nothing wrong with this – it’s all good stuff, until you get to the end of the lesson and think about what happens to that sheet. In my experience, some students diligently file it neatly away, some tuck it into their notebooks, and some put it into a bag, only for it to emerge weeks later, crumpled and forlorn, when they’re rummaging around for their homework. In all three scenarios I can guarantee one thing, however, and that is that the sheet has not been looked at since the lesson. It might as well have gone in the recycling bin on the way out.

I’ve puzzled for twenty years about how to help my students organise their work, and, in particular, record, learn and re-use new lexical items. This year I’m labelling every single sheet I give them as either ‘Language to Learn’, ‘Grammar’ (reference) or ‘Practice’. They have to keep the first two (in a file or stuck in a notebook – as they wish, just please not in a carrier bag), but the third they can keep if they want but I’m not encouraging it. In class, they write new lexical items in their ‘new words’ book and any other writing counts as ‘practice’ – they can use lined paper and file it if they want, or use a different notebook, but I don’t need them to keep this and it must be separate from where they record anything they want to learn or refer back to in the future. I’ve also now developed a system which works for me and aligns a Dogme or unplugged approach with knowledge organisers, retrieval practice and the kinds of activity which I’m convinced are important for putting new language into long-term memory. But that’s for a different post.

12

3

My attempts to order, streamline and simplify the way that I teach is most definitely connected to a wider impulse to de-clutter other aspects of my life. I’m not ashamed to say I jumped on the Konmari bandwagon some years ago and it really did change my life and it really did seem like magic. Overnight I went from hoarder to minimalist and I’ve since felt much less encumbered by stuff and free to focus on what I enjoy, learn new things, reflect more and even…start blogging. In not wanting my students to cling to unnecessary worksheets I feel a bit like an elderly relative clearing their house to save their descendants from having to do it once they’re gone.

I still have boxes of worksheets and notes in my attic from my language degree. In Konmari terms I consider them sentimental items, and whilst they don’t ‘spark joy’ I still find it hard to let them go, no matter how many times I remind myself that nostalgia is not my friend. I know this is probably unusual and as ease of discard goes, university and school notes are generally pretty easy for people to discard. I no doubt shouldn’t burden myself with the worry that I’m burdening my students with the same millstone further down the line.

But apart from this, I’m convinced that keeping hold of too much of the language learning clutter is not only unnecessary but can actually be detrimental to learning. I remember on my year abroad saying to a friend something like ‘when I get home I’m going to spend the summer going through my sheets and learning everything.’ I can’t remember her response but it was something like ‘don’t be silly – learn it now, bit by bit, and practise now, a little every day.’ But my sheets were disordered and I had no guidance as to what would actually be useful to commit to memory. I have a vivid memory of proudly demonstrating that I knew the Russian for ‘tungsten’ and yet struggling to say where I’d gone the day before (Russian verbs of motion are particularly tricky for English speakers). And of course I never did go through my notes, but I still kept hold of them, and I still intended to go through them ‘one day’, and I’ve still got them 20 years later.

My students’ lives are very busy. Some of them don’t have the study skills and none of them have the time to waste sorting through pieces of paper deciding what might be useful and deciding where to keep them and how to organise them, never mind actually using them for the vague purpose which they kept them for. When I tell them they don’t need to keep the ‘practice’ sheets they often say they want to keep them to practise at home. These days I respond to that by asking exactly what they are going to do with them. The answer is always something along the lines of ‘practise again’. As I know they will never get round to it, I would rather they just didn’t saddle themselves with an unnecessary intention in the first place which they then have to live with not fulfilling. If they really want to ‘practise again’, I can easily give them a blank sheet of grammar exercises or the reading comprehension or whatever it was to do again. This would not be a waste of time, but in terms of cost/benefit analysis there are things I would rather they were doing with their limited time which would have much more impact on their learning, namely memorising new lexical items and extensive reading.

So to go back to Ofsted and their ‘deep dive’. I suppose I can ask my students to do all their ‘practice’ writing in one notebook. I could even keep hold of it myself to produce when asked for, hopefully with enough notice to add some written feedback if that’s still clinging on as ‘best practice’, and then chuck on the bonfire the next 5th of November (can’t recycle – GDPR). But I long for the day when it’s enough to demonstrate progress for me to say ‘They couldn’t speak English before, but now they can’, and anyone who wants to check can come and chat to the student and maybe even ask them to read or write something then and there. I also want teachers to stop carefully curating paper-based evidence of their students’ progress which miraculously demonstrates all of their ILP targets, even when they know those pieces of work could never be reproduced. I want it to be OK for a teacher to say ‘If I’m honest, I don’t think my students are making progress,’ and start that magical, life-changing conversation: “What methodology do you subscribe to…? Have you tried this strategy…? I’ve found this kind of activity works really well with this group… Have you read this book…? Have you seen this website…? Have you read this blog…?

 

 

Where are you heading? – some brief thoughts on curriculum, syllabus, course outcomes and Dogme

A few days ago I took part in a webinar with Scott Thornbury. It was excellent and thought-provoking and can still be seen here: https://iateflesolsig.wordpress.com/2019/02/27/our-first-webinar-of-2019-is-this-thurdsay-book-you-spot-with-scoot-thornbury-now/

Also I got to ask my burning question: If I’m dealing with language items as they emerge, surely I won’t be dealing with them as well as if I’d planned in advance and had a carefully constructed lesson with a perfect context, good staging and engaging communicative activities which gave the students thorough practice of the item in all its forms? If you do access the webinar you’ll see I didn’t express my question exactly like that as I was trying to be succinct, but that was the idea.

Scott’s response, rather obviously: It’s a skill and it takes practice. I rankled a little at the insinuation that I might be a novice teacher, until it occurred to me that although I’ve been teaching for 18 years, I’ve only started incorporating elements of Dogme in the last two, and even then, not that often. So fair enough, it’s a skill I’m very much still in the early stages of developing, but so far it feels very worthwhile and enjoyable so I’m not too distressed by the idea that I’m going to need to work at it to get any better.

But today it occurred to me that underpinning my question was the approach to language learning that Dogme is attempting to rally against.  

By way of illustration: I’m currently teaching the 1st conditional with my Entry 3 class. I think I’m doing it quite well: nice context of a proposed trip to The Deep, discussion of all the things that could go wrong followed by what we’ll do if those things happen, and all the usual drilling, pair and cross-class q&a, followed by some freer practice with some ‘What will you do if…?’ questions. I’ve got a marker sentence on the IWB with the different clauses in different colours that I can move around to show that the if-clause can go at the beginning and the end of the sentence. It’s going quite well so far.

If I was teaching an ‘unplugged’ lesson and the 1st conditional came up I wouldn’t have any of that, so how would I deal with it well enough? But the answer to that question is unfortunately another question: ‘well enough’ for what?

Pretty much all my career has been in FE within the Skills for Life framework and I’ve happily engaged in criticising the Core Curriculum and certain exam boards, but always thinking how they could be different and how they could be better, never questioning whether we need them at all. But at the heart of Dogme, for all the useful suggestions about how the approach can be adopted within a school that has a prescribed syllabus or coursebook, is the idea that the learners’ own emergent language is all you need to drive the content of a course.

Back to the 1st conditional. Today I stopped and asked myself, Why am I teaching the 1st conditional? Why, when sketching out my scheme of work in September did I block out this week in February to be devoted to that? It’s because at the end of March some of my students will be sitting their writing exam, one task of which could involve them writing sentences from a given stem starting with ‘If’. With this end point in sight I’ve planned a carefully constructed flow of lessons that will end with them practising doing exactly that, and they’ll do it well and hopefully they’ll pass at least that part of the exam.

Today, for probably the first time, I’ve allowed myself to imagine a course that doesn’t end in an exam and that isn’t following a curriculum with prescribed language items which learners are expected to produce at each level. On this idyllic course where the content is exclusively driven, Dogme style, by the learners’ own needs and interests, they might never find the need to use a 1st conditional sentence, and if it did come up, helping them to construct the sentence they needed for that particular context would probably be all that was needed.

I wouldn’t need to dream up a context which exemplified typical and authentic use of the structure; if it had emerged in the course of the lesson, the context would already be established. I wouldn’t need to find some information gap exercise which required the learner to use the structure; they already want to use it to say whatever it is they’re trying to say. At most, I’d have to give them the sentence, guide them to analyse its form and maybe elicit other possible ways of finishing the sentence, all of which could easily be done on the hoof. The point at which I need to carefully plan how I’m going to present and practise the structure is the point at which it’s not yet starting to emerge naturally, but nevertheless the learners will soon have to produce it in exam conditions.

I’m imagining an alternative answer Scott Thornbury could have given to my question: “It’s a skill and it takes practice, but also try taking off the blinkers that are channelling you and your learners towards a particular linguistic destination; stop and look around at some of the things you’re missing on the way. But be careful – you might find it intoxicating.”

I am intoxicated by this idea and now a new question is lurking: I wonder how well my students would speak English if we leisurely ambled along that un-blinkered route?

Knowledge Organisers and Retrieval Practice in ESOL

A few months ago I took part in an action research project experimenting with knowledge organisers and retrieval practice activities with my Entry 3 ESOL class. Aside from the project itself, I discovered a world where people blog about education and ESOL. Excited but also nervous to join this world, here is my first blog, which is a reflection on the project.

Knowledge Organisers and Retrieval Practice Activities

Knowledge organisers are a bit of a thing right now, and plenty has been written about them. Briefly, they contain the key items of knowledge which students need to know as a minimum for a particular unit of a particular subject, organised on a single piece of A4 in such a way that students can self-test and memorise the information. Retrieval practice activities come from cognitive science research into learning and long-term memory, showing that the more practice the brain has at retrieving items from memory, the better they are remembered. Knowledge organisers go hand in hand with this as they can be used in and out of class in various ways which require the students to practise remembering the information on them.

Why I got excited about trying out knowledge organisers and retrieval practice activities with my ESOL class

I started teaching ESOL in 2001 when the Core Curriculum first came out. Even then, I was puzzled by the focus on skills, with grammar and lexis included within a few sub-skills almost as an afterthought. I understand this is due to the ESOL Curriculum being based on the Adult Literacy Curriculum, which of course has very little need to address vocabulary and grammar as it is for speakers of English as a first language.

Over the years I have reflected on the limitations of a skills-based curriculum. Of course there are students who need to practise skimming and scanning skills, but more often I find myself faced with learners for whom no amount of practice reading newspaper articles for gist will help them understand what they’re reading, because they don’t actually know what any of the words mean. A shift to raise the importance of structure and lexis – the ‘knowledge’ element of language if you like – alongside skills practice seems to me long overdue.

Another reason for my excitement was the solution knowledge organisers provide to the problem of how learners record and learn new language. I have experimented over the years with lexical notebooks and various ways to get learners to record language items which come up in class, such as advance organisers and gapped grammar reference sheets. Always with very little success. On balance, I have found the time needed to train students to organise and use their notebooks effectively would be better spent actually learning some English. A knowledge organiser gives them the language they need to know in an easily accessible place and the retrieval practice activities make sure they actually learn them.

As I learnt more about knowledge organisers and how to use them for retrieval practice I felt that this was the next logical step in the direction my teaching practice had been heading for the last few years, but also, paradoxically, it felt like a radical shift in mindset.

How I produced a knowledge organiser for my ESOL class and how I used it for retrieval practice

I decided to base my knowledge organiser on the Entry 3 speaking and listening exam my learners would be taking (we use Trinity). I looked at the exam syllabus and identified the words and phrases which I felt would be essential for successful completion of the tasks, and put these together as a table.

Here is what a section of my knowledge organiser looks like:

Capture

After some false starts, I settled into planning lessons in the way I usually do, except the focus of the lessons was the content of the knowledge organiser. Homework was to use the knowledge organiser for self-testing ready for a low-stakes test which I would give them next lesson. The test would usually be a section of the knowledge organiser with various words missing for the learners to recall. I also incorporated into my lessons activities and quizzes reviewing content of the organiser, often as a ‘do now’ activity or a warmer. The tests, activities and quizzes were on a cycle, with the same ones repeated at intervals.

Crucially, this was alongside, not replacing, more ‘normal’ lessons – reading texts, comprehension exercises, discussions etc. But also there are these key items of language which everyone knows, and I know everyone knows, and which we keep coming back to and using in different ways and different contexts.

Challenges

Choosing the right content is essential, but also very difficult. In ESOL we have the whole of the English language to choose from. I chose the language needed for exam tasks but topics or functions could easily underpin the choice of content.

Finding a way to make the knowledge organiser quizzable without relying on translation is also hard. I suggest my learners also write a translation and self-quiz from that, but for the class quizzes and tests I blanked out columns of the table so learners were using the images, or half of a sentence to practise recall.

Another potential pitfall is to care too much about the presentation of the organiser. Many teachers, myself included, seem seduced by the potential of technology to create beautiful and well-crafted materials. But the content is key. Preparation time is much better spent getting the content right rather than tweaking cell sizes.

The results of my action research project

My students generally responded well to the knowledge organisers with comments such as:

“Everything I have to know is in the yellow page and I can find it.”

and:

“When I write on the white paper you can’t remember which day… the yellow paper is clear.”

In an attempt to get some more quantitative data, I assessed the students according to the Trinity criteria at the beginning and end of the project. Obviously this was a subjective assessment, but what I did find was that there was a significant and unexpected improvement in the assessment criteria covering grammatical accuracy and range of structures. Tentatively, I concluded that memorising chunks of language which exemplify a target structure might be a more effective way of learning grammar than other more traditional methods. But that’s something to explore in a different project.

How my teaching has changed since the project

Bizarrely, I feel the changes I have made are relatively small and a natural progression from what I was doing previously, but in general my teaching has changed dramatically, and for the better.

In general, my planning and my lessons feel more streamlined. There’s more focus and a greater sense of purpose. There is still space to go off at a tangent, but I no longer get the frustrating feeling that an activity is a waste of time or that panic of not knowing what I’m going to teach and scrabbling around in textbooks for something that’ll do.

I repeat content much more than before. I’ve relinquished the idea that each lesson has to be something new and exciting and fresh. I repeat quizzes, drills and some homework sheets; I use the same discussion questions but change the groupings; I show the same pictures to elicit the same language again, and then take it further; I revisit texts to squeeze more language out of them; We rehearse and repeat role-plays until key functional phrases are memorised.

I’ve always given my students a test every lesson, but often this would be whatever vocab happened to come up in a reading text, or whatever happened to have been presented in a testable format on a worksheet. Now I put more thought into what I’m going to test and when – which items they need to know off by heart and when they’ll need to use them by. The items are already in a testable format on the knowledge organiser so all I have to do is tell the learners which section to learn for the test.

In addition to the action research project I’ve tried some Dogme-style lessons for the first time this year. Surprisingly, knowledge organisers and retrieval practice activities complemented this approach quite well, perhaps because they are also ‘materials-light’.  After a free and organic Dogme-style lesson, I take all the emergent language, select the most useful, and put it into a self-quizzable table using images or synonyms or whatever, and this then goes into the testing and retrieval practice cycle along with my ‘official’ knowledge organisers.

In general I rarely give my students anything that can’t later be revisited and quizzed.

Do knowledge organisers have a place in ESOL teaching?

In my opinion, the answer to this is a cautious yes. Whether you produce a knowledge organiser or not, the process of thinking about your group, and specifying which words and phrases you want them to be using at the end of the lesson / week / term or whatever, can radically change your teaching for the better. I’m not in a hurry to recommend ESOL departments across the country to start rolling out standardised knowledge organisers across all their courses. The nature of ESOL learners with their very different needs, different exam boards and syllabuses and the lack of any defined ‘knowledge’ at any one level makes this too complicated. I also think that it is the thinking process which the teacher goes through which is important, and which you wouldn’t get if you were simply handed a document to work with. Having said that, putting together a knowledge organiser is hugely time-consuming and, depending on what stage you’re at with your teaching, there might be other things you could do with your time which would have a bigger impact.

Retrieval practice activities, however, I think we should all be doing, and probably already are. Short snappy quizzes which force students to recall language items encountered last lesson, repeated lesson after lesson and mixed together in an endless cycle.

Above all, it does not have to be a choice between skills and knowledge. For too long, it seems to me, the emphasis of ESOL teaching has been on skills development at the expense of grammar and vocabulary. I’m merely advocating redressing that balance, not swinging the other way. My lessons these days are split roughly 50-50. The first half of the lesson has a language focus, and the second half will be based around a written or audio text, with plenty of speaking and some writing integrated into this broad structure.

Tips for ESOL  teachers thinking of trying knowledge organisers

  • Plan and teach in the usual way but use the knowledge organiser to decide the content of the lesson.
  • Focus on getting the content right and not on how nice the document looks.
  • Include blank space for learners to add items that come up.
  • Teach the students how to self-test using the knowledge organiser. Practise doing this in class time.
  • Print the knowledge organiser on coloured paper.
  • Don’t be afraid of over-learning and repeating the same quiz.